When Turkey was about 4 months old he started to get teeth, this also happens to be about the same time he stopped using a pacifier. We were lucky and never had to deal with the whole separation issues some kids have when it comes to the point when your kids should not using a pacifier anymore.
Raptor was even easier, he lasted about a month before he decided to give them up, it was actually quite difficult to get him to use one at all. We tried 3 or 4 different types of pacifiers before we finally just gave up, we think this was in part because he has a short Frenulum linguae which maybe made it hard for him to keep the pacifier in his mouth.
It’s certainly nice that we are past the pacifier stage, however we are running into a different problem which certainly relates – object based pacifiers, or as I like to now call - (OBP) 
When Turkey was first born my mother made an awesome blanket for for him, which he absolutely loves to this day despite how stained and gross it is. In addition to his blanket he also has a small stuffed dog, a stuffed Tigger and a sock monkey which he has all used at one point or another to replace the typical pacifier. He is now 3 years old and has naturally narrowed down his replacement pacifiers to just his blanket and his sock monkey. Thankfully he usually only chews on these things when he is tired, cranky or watching TV, otherwise he is pretty good about not having something in his mouth.
As far as Raptor goes, the only thing that comforted him at first was a stuffed Giraffe we had found, he immediately got attached to it and loves having it around, I expect this will turn into his new replacement pacifier.
So where do you draw the line? How long is it appropriate for your kids to shove a blanket or sock monkey or other objects into their mouths?
We are certainly to the point that we think it’s time to wean him off of his replacement pacifiers and just recently started doing so, it’s not going to happen over night but a few simple steps will get the process started.
Step One
Our first attack is to only allow him access to his blanket when he is upstairs in his room, it can’t be downstairs during the day and it’s only sometimes allowed downstairs in the evenings if we are watching a movie. We figure the less convenient it is for him to use it the better.
So far it’s been fairly successful, he likes to try to get away with bringing it downstairs once in a while but when we catch him we can usually just say “Is your blanket supposed to be downstairs?” or “Take your blanket upstairs please” and he will typically listen to us with only a little resistance.
At this point he is still allowed to have his monkey with him even when he is downstairs, we don’t want to make it too overwhelming for him at first.
Step Two
Eventually we will require that the monkey stays upstairs in his room also, at which point I expect we will try to get him to keep his blanket on his bed only, where it’s used for naptime (ha, naptime, I wish) and bed time. At this point it’s so inconvenient for him to chew on his blanket that he should just stop doing it.
Step Three
Burn the blanket and monkey! Ok, not really, but hopefully as the months go on he will learn that he doesn’t need to be chewing on something to comfort himself.
Other Tips:
- Don’t take replacement pacifier on short road trips
- Say “Why is your blanket in your mouth” and have them take it out
- Put the blanket out of site for long periods of time
- Put the blanket in the washing machine and dryer, make sure they see you do it so they know it’s “bath time” for his favorite things
Resistance
It’s quite possible that he will stop chewing on his blanket and even his monkey, but there is certainly the risk that he will replace them with something else. It could be another stuffed animal, his fingers, his clothes, etc. The key in those instances is to stop the behavior before it too becomes a habit.
I am always astonished when I see kids who are 3+ years old who still suck on an actual pacifier, if I was the parent I think it would drive me nuts and I’d likely be a bit embarrassed. Chewing on a blanket or monkey is bad enough.
When did your kids stop using pacifiers? Have they switched to replacement pacifiers like Turkey did? What solutions did you use to break the habit?